History features many unusual military encounters, but the 9th-century conflict in Scottish history between a Pictish nobleman and a Viking Earl ended with a rare fatality. In northern Scotland, an agreement to settle differences took a deceptive turn. A strictly negotiated 40-on-40 battle became an overwhelming massacre. However, the victorious Norse leader did not survive his journey home. A severed head strapped to a horse delivered a lethal strike. This is the documented account of Máel Brigte and Earl Sigurd the Mighty, where a dental anomaly caused a bizarre death.
Two Northern Rulers in Scottish History
During the late 800s, Sigurd Eysteinsson, known as Sigurd the Mighty, ruled as the Viking Earl of Orkney. He controlled northern territories extending down to the River Oykel. To the south in Moray, a Pictish nobleman named Máel Brigte held power. He possessed a prominent dental feature, earning him the name Máel Brigte the Bucktoothed. The two men were locked in a dispute. To resolve the conflict, they agreed to a formalized combat arrangement. Each leader would bring exactly 40 men to a battlefield to fight and settle their differences.
A Treacherous 80-Man Viking Army
On the day of the confrontation, Máel Brigte and his 40 warriors arrived at the designated location. As the opposing forces approached, the Pictish leader noticed an alarming detail. Looking at the cavalry, he saw two pairs of legs hanging against the flanks of every horse. Sigurd the Mighty had violated their agreement. Instead of 40 warriors, the Earl brought 80 men, mounting two soldiers on every horse to conceal his numbers. Realizing he was betrayed, Máel Brigte commanded his men to kill at least one enemy before falling. A fierce battle erupted, ending in the death of Máel Brigte and his fighters.
A Deadly Prize on a Saddle
Following the combat, Sigurd the Mighty claimed a grisly prize. The Earl ordered his men to decapitate the defeated Picts and strap the severed heads to their saddles. Sigurd personally took the head of Máel Brigte and attached it to his own saddle. As the Norsemen rode away, the movement of the horse caused the severed head to bounce. During the ride, Máel Brigte’s prominent bucktooth pierced the skin of Sigurd’s leg, leaving a deep scratch.
The Fatal Scratch and Burial Mound
The minor wound from the tooth quickly became inflamed. The scratch caused a severe infection that spread rapidly through Sigurd’s body. The Earl of Orkney died shortly after as a direct result of the scratch inflicted by his dead opponent. Sigurd was buried in a mound on the banks of the River Oykel. Máel Brigte’s power center was near modern Inverness, located roughly 44 miles (70.8 kilometers) away. A 13th-century farm in the burial area was recorded as Syvardhoch, meaning “Sigurd’s mound,” and the location near Dornoch is known today as Cyderhall.
Wikipedia